Article    Peer-Reviewed

Uncovering the Holistic Pathways to Circular Cities—The Case of Alberta, Canada

Marjan Marjanović 1,* , Wendy Wuyts 2, Julie Marin 3 and Joanna Williams 1
Bartlett School of Planning, University College London, London WC1H 0NN, UK
Department of Manufacturing and Civil Engineering, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, 2815 Gjøvik, Norway
Department of Architecture, KU Leuven, 3001 Leuven, Belgium
For correspondence.
Academic Editor:
Highlights Sustain. 2022, 1(2), 65–87.
Received: 28 February 2022    Accepted: 3 May 2022    Published: 6 May 2022
The notion of circularity has gained significant attention from governments of many cities across the world. The approaches to circular cities may range from narrower perspectives that see a circular city as the simple sum of circular economy initiatives to those more holistic that aim to integrate the whole urban system. Several researchers proposed frameworks that would guide cities to take a holistic perspective. This manuscript selects two frameworks and examines through them whether and to what extent broader and more holistic approaches to circular cities are being developed in practice. First, circularity principles, the scope of circular activities, and the concrete circular actions developed in the case study are read through Williams’s approach to circular resource management. Second, the spatial circularity drivers framework of Marin and De Meulder is used to elucidate different sustainability framings and spatial practices that dominate contemporary conceptualisations of circularity. These two lenses are applied to five municipalities in Alberta (Canada) that have decided to develop strategies for ‘shifting the paradigm’ and transitioning to circular cities in 2018. Our study aims to investigate how holistic their roadmaps to circular cities are, and what changes are necessary to move towards more integrated approaches.
Figures in this Article
Copyright © 2022 Marjanović et al. This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use and distribution provided that the original work is properly cited.
The research by M.M. is funded by the Graduate Research Scholarship and the Overseas Research Scholarship of University College London. The work by W.W. is self-funded. J.M. is funded by Research Foundation—Flanders (FWO) grant nr 12Z9420N. The work by J.W. is paid for by University College London.
Cite this Article
ACS Style
Marjanović, M.; Wuyts, W.; Marin, J.; Williams, J. Uncovering the Holistic Pathways to Circular Cities—The Case of Alberta, Canada. Highlights Sustain. 2022, 1, 65–87.
APA Style
Marjanović, M., Wuyts, W., Marin, J., & Williams, J. (2022). Uncovering the Holistic Pathways to Circular Cities—The Case of Alberta, Canada. Highlights of Sustainability, 1(2), 65–87.
Campbell-Johnston, K.; ten Cate, J.; Elfering-Petrović, M.; Gupta, J. City level circular transitions: Barriers and limits in Amsterdam, Utrecht and The Hague. J. Clean. Prod. 2019, 235, 1232–1239.
Korhonen, J.; Nuur, C.; Feldmann, A.; Birkie, S.E. Circular economy as an essentially contested concept. J. Clean. Prod. 2018, 175, 544–552.
Milios, L. Advancing to a Circular Economy: three essential ingredients for a comprehensive policy mix. Sustain. Sci. 2018, 13, 861–878.
Galli, A.; Kitzes, J.; Niccolucci, V.; Wackernagel, M.; Wada, Y.; Marchettini, N. Assessing the global environmental consequences of economic growth through the ecological footprint: a focus on China and India. Ecol. Indic. 2012, 17, 99–107.
Prendeville, S.; Cherim, E.; Bocken, N. Circular cities: mapping six cities in transition. Environ. Innov. Soc. Transit. 2018, 26, 171–194.
Krausmann, F.; Gingrich, S.; Eisenmenger, N.; Erb, K.H.; Haberl, H.; Fischer-Kowalski, M. Growth in global materials use, GDP and population during the 20th century. Ecol. Econ. 2009, 68, 2696–2705.
Moore, D.; Cranston, G.; Reed, A.; Galli, A. Projecting future human demand on the Earth’s regenerative capacity. Ecol. Indic. 2012, 16, 3–10.
Obersteg, A.; Arlati, A.; Acke, A.; Berruti, G.; Czapiewski, K.; Dabrowski, M.; Heurkens, E.; Mezei, C.; Palestino, M.F.; Varjú, V.; et al. Urban regions shifting to circular economy: Understanding challenges for new ways of governance. Urban Plan. 2019, 4, 1–13.
Chávez, A.; Kennedy, C.; Chen, B.; Chertow, M.; Baynes, T.; Chen, S.; Bai, X. Understanding, implementing, and tracking urban metabolism is key to urban futures. In Urban planet: Knowledge towards sustainable cities, Elmqvist, T., Bai, X., Frantzeskaki, N., Griffith, C., Maddox, D., McPhearson, T., Parnell, S., Romero-Lankao, P., Simon, D., Watkins, M., Eds.; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 2018; pp. 68–91.
Williams, J. Circular cities: Challenges to implementing looping actions. Sustainability 2019, 11, 423.
Swilling, M.; Robinson, B.; Marvin, S.; Hodson, M.; Hajer, M. City-level decoupling: urban resource flows and the governance of infrastructure transitions. A report of the working group on cities of the international resource panel; United Nations Environment Programme: Nairobi, Kenya, 2013.
Camaren, P.; Swilling, M. Sustainable Resource Efficient Cities: Making It Happen; United Nations Environment Programme: Nairobi, Kenya, 2012.
Franco, M.A. Circular economy at the micro level: A dynamic view of incumbents’ struggles and challenges in the textile industry. J. Clean. Prod. 2017, 168, 833–845.
Dobbs, R.; Oppenheim, J.; Thompson, F. Mobilizing for a resource revolution. McKinsey Q. 2012.
Ghisellini, P.; Cialani, C.; Ulgiati, S. A review on circular economy: the expected transition to a balanced interplay of environmental and economic systems. J. Clean. Prod. 2016, 114, 11–32.
Kirchherr, J.; Reike, D.; Hekkert, M. Conceptualising the circular economy: An analysis of 114 definitions. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 2017, 127, 221–232.
Hashimoto, S.; Fischer‐Kowalski, M.; Suh, S.; Bai, X. Greening growing giants: a major challenge of our planet. J. Ind. Ecol. 2012, 16, 459–466.
Williams, J. Circular cities. Urban Stud. 2019, 56, 2746–2762.
Liang, S.; Zhang, T. Urban metabolism in China achieving dematerialization and decarbonization in Suzhou. J. Ind. Ecol. 2011, 15, 420–434.
Fratini, C.F.; Georg, S.; Jørgensen, M.S. Exploring circular economy imaginaries in European cities: A research agenda for the governance of urban sustainability transitions. J. Clean. Prod. 2019, 228, 974–989.
Geng, Y.; Zhu, Q.; Doberstein, B.; Fujita, T. Implementing China’s circular economy concept at the regional level: A review of progress in Dalian, China. Waste Manag. 2009, 29, 996–1002.
Deckmyn, S. Circular Flanders: Adaptive Policy for a Circular Economy. In Factor X; Springer: Cham, Switzerland; pp. 335–346.
European Commission. Closing the Loop: An EU Action Plan for the Circular Economy. Available online: (accessed 26 February 2022)
Marin, J.; De Meulder, B. Interpreting circularity. Circular city representations concealing transition drivers. Sustainability 2018, 10, 1310.
Montenegro Navarro, N.; Jonker, J. Circular City Governance - An explorative research study into current barriers and governance practices in circular city transitions across Europe; European Investment Bank: Luxembourg, Luxembourg, 2018.
Schulze, G. Growth Within: A Circular Economy Vision for a Competitive Europe; Ellen MacArthur Foundation: Cowes, UK, 2016.
Williams, J. Circular Cities: A Revolution in Urban Sustainability; Routledge: London, UK, 2021.
Bastein, A.G.T.M.; Verstraeten-Jochemsen, J.N.; Rietveld, E.; Hauck, M.; Frijters, E.; Klijn, O.; Driessen, B. Circular Amsterdam. A vision and action agenda for the city and metropolitan area; TNO: Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2016.
Marin, J. De Meulder, B. Antwerp City Wastescapes. Historic interplays between waste and urban development. Int. Plan. Hist. Soc. Proc. 2016, 17, 179–190.
Paiho, S.; Mäki, E.; Wessberg, N.; Paavola, M.; Tuominen, P.; Antikainen, M.; Heikkilä, J.; Antuña Rozado, K.; Jung, N. Towards circular cities—Conceptualizing core aspects. Sustain. Cities Soc. 2020, 59, 102143.
Williams, J. Circular Cities: What Are the Benefits of Circular Development? Sustainability 2021, 13, 5725.
Brunner, P.H. Urban mining a contribution to reindustrializing the city. J. Ind. Ecol. 2011, 15, 339–341.
Li, J. Wastes could be resources and cities could be mines. Waste Manag. Res. 2015, 33, 301–302.
Willems, E.; Kuhk, A. Circulariteit. Nieuwe blauwdruk voor duurzaamheid (in Dutch)? Ruimte 2021, 49, 10–13.
Krook, J.; Svensson, N.; Eklund, M. Landfill mining: A critical review of two decades of research. Waste Manag. 2012, 32, 513–520.
Tapia, C.; Bianchi, M.; Pallaske, G.; Bassi, A.M. Towards a territorial definition of a circular economy: exploring the role of territorial factors in closed-loop systems. Eur. Plan. Stud. 2021, 29, 1438–1457.
Williams, J. The role of spatial planning in transitioning to circular urban development. Urban Geogr. 2020, 41, 915–919.
Tsui, T.; Peck, D.; Geldermans, B.; van Timmeren, A. The Role of Urban Manufacturing for a Circular Economy in Cities. Sustainability 2021, 13, 23.
Veyssière, S.; Laperche, B.; Blanquart, C. Territorial development process based on the circular economy: a systematic literature review. Eur. Plan. Stud. 2021.
Virtanen, M.; Manskinen, K.; Uusitalo, V.; Syvänne, J.; Cura, K. Regional material flow tools to promote circular economy. J. Clean. Prod. 2019, 235, 1020–1025.
Van den Berghe, K.B.; Verhagen, T.J. Making it Concrete: Analysing the Role of Concrete Plants Locations for Circular City Policy Goals. Front. Built Environ. 2021, 136.
Levoso, A.S.; Gasol, C.M.; Martínez-Blanco, J.; Durany, X.G.; Lehmann, M.; Gaya, R.F. Methodological framework for the implementation of circular economy in urban systems. J. Clean. Prod. 2020, 248, 119227.
Bolger, K.; Doyon, A. Circular cities: exploring local government strategies to facilitate a circular economy. Eur. Plan. Stud. 2019, 27, 2184–2205.
Wuyts, W.; Sedlitzky, R.; Morita, M.; Tanikawa, H. Understanding and Managing Vacant Houses in Support of a Material Stock-Type Society—The Case of Kitakyushu, Japan. Sustainability 2020, 12, 5363.
Christensen, T.B. Towards a circular economy in cities: Exploring local modes of governance in the transition towards a circular economy in construction and textile recycling. J. Clean. Prod. 2021, 305, 127058.
Dagilienė, L.; Varaniūtė, V.; Bruneckienė, J. Local governments’ perspective on implementing the circular economy: A framework for future solutions. J. Clean. Prod. 2021, 310, 127340.
Heshmati, A.; Rashidghalam, M. Assessment of the urban circular economy in Sweden. J. Clean. Prod. 2021, 310, 127475.
Papageorgiou, A.; Henrysson, M.; Nuur, C.; Sinha, R.; Sundberg, C.; Vanhuyse, F. Mapping and assessing indicator-based frameworks for monitoring circular economy development at the city-level. Sustain. Cities Soc. 2021, 75, 103378.
Friant, M.C.; Vermeulen, W.J.; Salomone, R. A typology of circular economy discourses: Navigating the diverse visions of a contested paradigm. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 2020, 161, 104917.
Moreau, V.; Sahakian, M.; Van Griethuysen, P.; Vuille, F. Coming full circle: why social and institutional dimensions matter for the circular economy. J. Ind. Ecol. 2017, 21, 497–506.
Millar, N.; McLaughlin, E.; Börger, T. The circular economy: swings and roundabouts? Ecol. Econ. 2019, 158, 11–19.
Growth Within: A Circular Economy Vision for a Competitive Europe. Available online: (accessed 26 February 2022).
McDonough, W.; Braungart, M. Cradle to cradle: Remaking the way we make things; North Point Press: New York, NY, USA, 2010.
Stahel, W.R. The Performance Economy; Palgrave Macmillan: London, UK, 2010.
Van der Voet, E.; van Oers, L.; Nikolic, I. Dematerialization: not just a matter of weight. J. Ind. Ecol. 2004, 8, 121–137.
Williams, J. Circular Cities: Strategies, Challenges and Knowledge Gaps; Circular Cities Hub: London, UK, 2017.
Marin, J.; De Meulder, B. Time is Life. Ruimte 2021, 49, 22–25.
Wuyts, W.; Marjanović, M. The Development of Spatial Circularity Discourse in Japan: Ecomodernist, Territorialised, or Both? The Story of Onomichi’s Wastescapes. Circ. Econ. Sustain. 2022.
Vandenbroeck, P. Towards an Urban-Metabolic Agenda for a Circular Future; OVAM, FABRIC, VMM, Team Vlaams Bouwmeester and Metabolism of Cities: Brussels, Belgium, 2017.
Vandenbroeck, P. Een metabolische manier van naar de wereld te kijken (in Dutch); Labo Ruimte: Brussels, Belgium, 2017.
Barles, S. Urban metabolism and river systems: an historical perspective–Paris and the Seine, 1790–1970. Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci. 2007, 11, 1757–1769. https:/
Barles, S. Urban metabolism of Paris and its region. J. Ind. Ecol. 2009, 13, 898–913.
Graedel, T.E.; Lifset, R.J. Industrial ecology’s first decade. In Taking stock of industrial ecology; Clift, R., Druckman, A., Eds.; Springer: Cham, Switzerland, 2016; pp. 3–20.
Danneels, K.; Juwet, G.; Bruggeman, D. Urban metabolism: From theoretical concept to tangible practice. AGORA Mag. 2018, 34, 4–7.
Barles, S. History of Waste Manag. and the social and cultural representations of waste. In The basic environmental history; Agnoletti M., Serneri S.N., Eds.; Springer: Cham, Switzerland, 2014; pp. 199–226.
Miatto, A.; Schandl, H.; Forlin, L.; Ronzani, F.; Borin, P.; Giordano, A.; Tanikawa, H. A spatial analysis of material stock accumulation and demolition waste potential of buildings: A case study of Padua. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 2019, 142, 245–256.
Guo, J.; Fishman, T.; Wang, Y.; Miatto, A.; Wuyts, W.; Zheng, L.; Wang, H.; Tanikawa, H. Urban development and sustainability challenges chronicled by a century of construction material flows and stocks in Tiexi, China. J. Ind. Ecol. 2021, 25, 162–175.
Sultana, F. Political ecology 1: From margins to center. Prog. Hum. Geogr. 2020, 45, 156–165.
Swyngedouw, E.; Heynen, N.C. Urban political ecology, justice and the politics of scale. Antipode 2003, 35, 898–918.
Fischer‐Kowalski, M. Society’s metabolism: the intellectual history of materials flow analysis, Part I, 1860–1970. J. Ind. Ecol. 1998, 2, 61–78.
Marin, J. Circulariteit ontwerpen: Vier agendas (in Dutch). AGORA Mag. 2018, 4, 16–19.
Marin, J.; Alaerts, L.; Van Acker, K. A Materials Bank for Circular Leuven: How to Monitor ‘Messy’Circular City Transition Projects. Sustainability 2020, 12, 10351.
Lodder, M.; Roorda, C.; Loorbach, D.; Spork, C. Staat van Transitie: patronen van opbouw en afbraak in vijf domeinen (in Dutch); Erasmus Universiteit Rotterdam: Drift, The Netherlands, 2017.
Recycling Council of Alberta. Circular Cities Project. Available online: (accessed 28 February 2022).
Petoskey, J.; Stults, M.; Naples, E.; Hardy, G.; Quilici, A.; Byerly, C.; Clark, A.; Newton, D.; Santiago, E.; Teener, J. Envisioning a Circular Economy: The Journey of One Mid-Sized Midwestern City. Sustainability 2021, 13, 3157.
Canada Cities. Circular Cities & Regions Initiative. Available online: (accessed 28 February 2022).
Recycling Council of Alberta. Circular Cities Webinar. Available online: (accessed on: 28 February 2022)
Drisko, J.W.; Maschi, T. Content analysis; Oxford University Press: New York, NY, USA, 2016.
Ahuvia, A. Traditional, interpretive, and reception based content analyses: Improving the ability of content analysis to address issues of pragmatic and theoretical concern. Soc. Indic. Res. 2001, 54, 139–172.
Lukkarinen, J.P.; Nieminen, H.; Lazarevic, D. Transitions in planning: transformative policy visions of the circular economy and blue bioeconomy meet planning practice. Eur. Plan. Stud. 2022.
What is a circular economy? A framework for an economy that is restorative and regenerative by design. Available online: (accessed 28 February 2022).
Recycling Council of Alberta. City of Calgary Circular Cities Roadmap. Available online: (accessed 28 February 2022).
Van den Berghe, K.; Vos, M. Circular Area Design or Circular Area Functioning? A Discourse-Institutional Analysis of Circular Area Developments in Amsterdam and Utrecht, The Netherlands. Sustainability 2019, 11, 4875.
Town of Banff Circular Cities Roadmap. Available online: (accessed 28 February 2022).
City of Edmonton Circular Communities Roadmap. Available online: (accessed 28 February 2022).
City of Lethbridge Circular Cities Roadmap. Available online: (accessed 28 February 2022).
Strathcona County Circular Cities Roadmap. Available online: (accessed 28 February 2022).
Kuhk, A.; Luyten, E.; Willems, E. Welke circulaire toekomst willen we (in Dutch)? Ruimte 2021, 49, 70–75.
The Circular Economy in Umeå, Sweden. Available online: (accessed 28 February 2022).
Nylén, E. Can Abstract Ideas Generate Change? The Case of the Circular Economy. In Leading Change in a Complex World: Transdisciplinary Perspectives; Kangas, A., Kujala, J., Heikkinen, A., Lönqvist, A., Laihonen, H., Bethwaite, J., Eds.; Tampere University Press: Tampere, Finland, 2019; pp. 281–300.
Innovation for a circular economy: learning from the clean growth journey. Available online: (accessed 28 February 2022).
Voß, J.-P.; Simons, A. Instrument constituencies and the supply side of policy innovation: The social life of emissions trading. Environ. Politics 2014, 23, 735–754.
Chembessi, C.; Beaurain, C.; Cloutier, G. Building territorial value within local circular economy’s projects: lessons from French scholars’ studies. Local Environ. 2021, 26, 1145–1151.
Bianchi, M.; Cordella, M; Menger, P. Regional monitoring frameworks for the circular economy: implications from a territorial perspective. Eur. Plan. Stud. 2022.
Tsing, A.L; Mathews, A.S.; Bubandt, N. Patchy Anthropocene: Landscape Structure, Multispecies History, and the Retooling of Anthropology. Curr. Anthropol. 2019, 60, 186–197.
Sheikh, H.; Foth, M.; Mitchell, P. More-than-human city-region foresight: multispecies entanglements in regional governance and planning. Reg. Stud. 2022.
Wuyts, W.; Marin, J. “Nobody” matters in circular landscapes. Local Environ. 2022.
Journal Menu
Journal Contact
Highlights of Sustainability Editorial Office
Highlights of Science
Avenida Madrid, 189-195, 3-3
08014 Barcelona, Spain
Tel. +34 93 138 23 89
Cathy Wang Managing Editor
Submit Your Article
Highlights Sustain., ISSN 2696-628X. Published quarterly by Highlights of Science.
Subscribe to read the latest articles and newsletters from Highlights of Science.